Report
Strengthening Immunization Service Experience: Ghana
After rising for more than two decades, routine immunization coverage rates began to stagnate in 2010, with an estimated 19.4 million children under the age of one not receiving basic vaccines in 2018. While immunization services have historically focused on supply and delivery functions, inequities have highlighted the significance of demand generation—and the need for a people-centered model that incorporates health worker and client perspectives for a more positive immunization service experience.
Partners in the Vaccination Demand Hub Service Experience Workstream are collaborating to inform a new direction in people-centered quality immunization service delivery and re-orient immunization services to include caregiver, client and health worker perspectives and needs. In support of this effort, John Snow Research & Training Institute, Inc. (JSI), in collaboration with Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, consolidated existing knowledge and conducted rapid learning around immunization service experience at global and regional levels through desk reviews and key informant interviews (KIIs). Results from these KIIs were organized
into nine main components. These components formed the basis for additional insight gathering in four countries, including Ghana. The Ghana Health Service (GHS) mainstreamed quality health services approximately two decades ago with the adoption of several policies and programs, including the creation of a Quality Assurance Strategy, new protocols and guidelines, and the five-year National Healthcare Quality Strategy (NHQS) adopted in 2016. However, these frameworks do not provide guidance on how to improve the quality of immunization services or the service experience for clients, communities, and
service providers.
To understand if and how the global and regional findings resonate in country (and efforts underway in Ghana to address the immunization service experience), in June and July 2020, JSI conducted a review of the grey and peer-reviewed literature to gather the following information:
- The experience of clients and caregivers in the healthcare system
- Health system and facility factors that affect the immunization service experience
- Health worker and client factors and perceptions that impact service delivery and experience
- Community contributions to service design and delivery
The published and grey literature were identified through a web-based search and suggestions gathered from key stakeholders. The search, which yielded over 46 documents, focused on immunization issues as
well as maternal, newborn and child health, HIV/AIDS, family planning, and antenatal care. Additional information was obtained from 13 key informants representing the Ghana health sector. Following analysis
of the literature review and interviews, the GHS EPI team also met to provide input and build consensus on the recommendations.
This case study shares findings from the literature review and KIIs and offers practical recommendations to improve the immunization service experience for clients, caregivers, and health workers in Ghana.
Languages
- English
Publication year
2022
Type
Report
Categories
- Vaccines & delivery devices
Countries
- Ghana
Organisations
- John Snow, Inc (JSI)
Tags
- Demand
- EQUIP
- Immunization information systems
WHO Regions
- African Region
Demand Hub
The resource is included in the following table:
| Title | Author | Year | Type | Language |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Service Experience Orientation Presentation | JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, Vaccination Demand Hub | 2022 | Tool | English |
| Service Experience Getting Started Guide | JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc, Vaccination Demand Hub, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance | 2022 | Tool | English, French |
| Nigeria - Messages and Trusted mesengers acceptance_Chizoba Wonodi | Chizoba Wonodi | 2021 | Presentation | English |
| Facteurs comportementaux et sociaux de la vaccination : outils et conseils pratiques pour parvenir à une adoption vaccinale élevée | World Health Organization (WHO), UNICEF | 2022 | Case study | French |
| Human-centred design for tailoring immunization programmes | World Health Organization (WHO) | 2022 | Guidance | English, French, Portuguese, Spanish |
| Behavioural and social drivers of vaccination: tools and practical guidance for achieving high uptake | World Health Organization (WHO) | 2022 | Guidance | Arabic, English, French, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish |
| Quality immunization services: a planning guide | World Health Organization (WHO) | 2022 | Guidance | Arabic, English, Russian, French, Portuguese, Spanish |
| Health worker communication for COVID-19 vaccination - Flow diagram for communicating during COVID-19 vaccination sessions | World Health Organization (WHO) | 2021 | Poster/infographic | English |
| Conducting community engagement for COVID-19 vaccines: Interim guidance | World Health Organization (WHO), UNICEF | 2021 | Guidance | Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Portuguese, Russian, Spanish |
| Acceptance and demand for COVID-19 vaccines: Interim guidance | World Health Organization (WHO), UNICEF | 2021 | Guidance | English |
| Vaccine misinformation management guide: Guidance for addressing a global infodemic and fostering demand for immunization | UNICEF, First Draft, Yale Institute for Global Health (YIGH), The Public Good Projects (PGP) | 2020 | Guidance | Arabic, French, Italian, Spanish, Turkish |
| RDC - Ecouter et Agir les plus vulnerables - Croix Rouge RDC | RDC Red cross | 2021 | Presentation | French |
| DRC - High Volume Vaccination Site Experience | VillageReach | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| India - Assam Mobile Vans and Community Engagement to increase uptake in hard to reach | Anumegha Bhatnagar | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Bangladesh - Community Radio in Bangladesh | Breakthrough ACTION | 2023 | Presentation | English |
| Cote d'Ivoire - Using rumor management system data to develop adaptive COVID-19 vaccination strategies | Breakthrough ACTION | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Syria - Bringing the service closer to communities | Syrian Arab Red Crescent | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Sierra Leone - RCT of last mile vaccine delivery | Maarten Voors | 2022 | Case study | English |
| Cameroon - Community Dialogue and Microplanning - Value Health Africa | Mbianke Livancliff | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Cote d'Ivoire - Hackathon - Geneva Learning Foundation | Charlotte Mbuh | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Fiji - Social Listening - UNICEF Pacific | Kshitij Joshi | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Ghana - Closing Loop Digital Media - UNICEF | Hameed Kashan, Anastasiia Nurzhynska | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Malawi - SMS to address rumours - Malawi Red Cross | Arnav Kapur, Joseph Mwase | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Nigeria - Demand creation - Red Cross | Nigerian Red Cross | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Pakistan - Vaccination Related Restrictions - Faisal Khalil | Muhammad Faisal Khalil | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Solomon Islands - Transfer knowledge and promoting community actions - Red Cross | Kennedy Waitara | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Tanzania - Evidence to Action - Chima Onuekwe | Chima E. Onuekwe | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Viet Nam - Hearing and addressing vaccine related concerns - UNICEF Viet Nam | Giap Nguyen | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Tanzania - COVID-19 vaccine equity and access for older people | HelpAge International, Joseph Mbasha | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Operational Framework for Demand Promotion - Integration | UNICEF, World Health Organization (WHO), Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Vaccination Demand Hub, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) | 2023 | Guidance | English, French, Portuguese |
| Cadre Opérationnel Pour la Promotion de la Demande - Intégration de la vaccination contre la COVID-19 | UNICEF, World Health Organization (WHO), United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, Vaccination Demand Hub, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) | 2024 | Guidance | French, English, Portuguese |
| Quadro operacional para promoção da procura - Integração da vacinação contra a COVID-19 | UNICEF, World Health Organization (WHO), Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, Vaccination Demand Hub, International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC), United States Agency for International Development (USAID), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) | 2024 | Guidance | Portuguese, English, French |
| Understanding the behavioural and social drivers of vaccine uptake WHO position paper – May 2022 | World Health Organization (WHO) | 2022 | Guidance | English, French |
| HPV Vaccination: A Guide for Planning and Designing Demand Promotion Interventions | UNICEF | 2024 | User guide | English |
| Misinformation: A Strategic Approach | Sabin Vaccine Institute, UNICEF | 2020 | Webinar | English |
| GENDER AND IMMUNIZATION DEMAND (FINAL REPORT) | UNICEF, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance | 2022 | Guidance | English, French, Spanish |
| GENDER AND IMMUNIZATION DEMAND (checklist) | UNICEF, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance | 2021 | Guidance | English, French, Spanish |
| From coverage to empowerment: Integrating gender in immunization demand. Promising practices from six countries. | UNICEF, Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance | 2022 | Case study | English, French, Spanish |
| Social Listening (Cameroon) | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Renforcement de l'engagement communautaire pour la vaccination de routine et l'enregistrement des naissances | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | French |
| Plan Mashako, atteindre les "zéro dose" | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | French |
| DRC Red Cross experience in integrating Covid-19 vaccination into routine immunization | International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) | 2022 | Case study | English |
| Application of Human Centered Design and Behavioral and Social Drivers of Vaccination in Ethiopia | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Demand Intensification through Community Engagement (D.I.C.E) | Jayne Kariuki | 2022 | Presentation | English |
| Use of Human-Centered Design (HCD) in Madagascar | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Integration of COVID-19 vaccination, RI, and MNCAH together and with other sectors in Madagascar | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Rapid assessment on caregiver’s perceptions of immunization services | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Integration of immunization and other primary health care services in Nigeria | Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Case Study: Somalia. RCCE for COVID-19 Vaccine Demand in Eastern and Southern Africa. | UNICEF | 2023 | Case study | English |
| Tanzania: Working with multiple partners to shift community perception and increase uptake of the COVID-19 vaccine. | UNICEF, Vaccination Demand Hub | 2023 | Case study | English |
Immunization Service Experience
The resource is included in the following table: